Welcome to Calico Toy Shoppe Learn more
New Online Shopping! See all we offer
NOTE: We don't currently ship orders, but we do support online orders for local pickup.
Crazy Aaron's Putty World
Cosmic Glows: Infinite Nebula
Create & Melt: Mythic Mix Up
Dough Cups: Learning Numbers Kit
Happy Hedgehog
Hide Inside: Gnome Home
Hypercolors: Magic Dragon
Popp'n Thinking Putty: Crackle'n Kraken
Slime Charmers: Dumpster Dive
Slime Charmers: Mini Mini Mart
Think 2": Avocado
Think 2": Coral Reef
Think 2": Cryptocurrency
Think 2": Daydream
Think 2": Eternal Flame
Think 2": Fairy Sprinkles
Think 2": Halloween
Think 2": Pirate's Cove
Think 2": Rock N Roll
Think 2": Rose Gold
Think 2": Sun Beam
Think 2": Treasure Surprise *
Trendetters: Birthstone
Trendsetter: Honey Hive
Trendsetters: Comic Book
Your cart is empty
Subtotal:$000 USD
Loading...
We're a Real Store
We'll help you find the perfect gift
Check your order status
Updates & Past Orders
Returns & exchanges
All you need to know
Follow Us!
Visit Our Social Pages for the very latest pictures and store information